Flummery (pronounced fluhm-uh-ree)
(1) Oatmeal or flour boiled with water until thick (historically, a slightly tart, jelly-like food of Welsh origin, made from extensively boiling oats, then boiling down the liquid extracted from it).
(2) A fruit custard or blancmange, any of several bland, gelatinous foodstuffs, made usually from stewed fruit and thickened with oatmeal, cornstarch or flour.
(3) In speech or writing, complete nonsense; foolish humbug; words devoid of meaning (applied especially of flattery); deceptive or blustering speech (applied especially in politics and, as an interjection, an expression of contemptuous disbelief).
(4) Pretentious trappings, useless embellishments or ornaments intended to impress (applied to architecture, interior decorating, fashion etc).
1623: From the Welsh llymru (which was assimilated into English with an –ery
ending) of uncertain origin but there may be some link with llymrig (slippery). The figurative use to describe
flattery or empty, meaningless talk, is from the 1740s. Flummery is a noun; the noun plural is flummeries.
The Welsh llymru was “a jelly derived from oatmeal”, the name first noted in English poet Gervase Markham's (circa 1568–1637) Countrey Contentments (1623) and was known also as wash-brew although in Lancashire and Cheshire, it was called flamerie or flumerie. The modern spelling was one of the variant forms which in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries also included thlummery and flamery. By the nineteenth century, flummery had become the standard form, both to describe bland, unsatisfying food and unsubstantial talk or writing, and nonsense. The US food with similar meanings is Mead Johnson's pablum, a soft, bland cereal, intended for infants, invalids and the weak. In post-war Australia, a flummery was the name given to a mousse dessert made with beaten evaporated milk, sugar, and gelatine. Also made using jelly crystals, mousse flummery became popular as an inexpensive alternative to traditional cream-based mousse. In the US, it was named blancmange.
Pabulum
(pronounced pab-yuh-luhm)
(1) Something that
nourishes an animal or vegetable organism; food; nutriments.
(2) Figuratively, food for thought (can be neutral or positive but is more commonly used of material thought bland, dull or intellectually undemanding).
(3) Material that fuels a fire (now rare except in technical documents).
1670-1680: From the Classical Latin pābulum (food, nourishment; fodder or pasture for animals; nourishment for the mind, food for thought), the construct being pā(scō) (to nourish) + bulum (the suffix denoting an instrument). Root was the primitive Indo-European peh-dlom, the construct being pe- (to feed) or peh- (to protect; to shepherd) + -dlom (a variant of -trom (the suffix denoting a tool or instrument)). In the early eighteenth century the adjective pabulary (of or pertaining to pabulum (in the sense of food) and from the Latin pabulosus (abounding in fodder)) enjoyed a brief vogue as a noun (an eating place or a counter in an inn from which meals were served). Pablum is a noun, pabular is a verb, pabulous, pabular & pabulary are adjectives; the noun plural is pabulums.
Crooked Spiro & Tricky Dick: Spiro Agnew and Richard Nixon.
The word in the late seventeenth century was used of food in the widest sense (ie that which feeds or nourishes) and that applied to that taken by people, animals, agricultural crops (in the sense of fertilizer) and even the material used to fuel a fire. A trademark of manufacturers Mead Johnson, Pablum is a soft, bland cereal, intended for infants, invalids and the weak which was released in 1932 and it was this association which was picked up in the figurative use made of pabulum (to describe vapid or mushy political prose) in a speech made on 11 September 1970 by Spiro Agnew (1918–1996; US vice president 1969-1973). The tone of the speech (though perhaps not the labored syntax which would be rejected as TLDR (too long, didn’t read) in the social media age) would be familiar to modern audiences used to political figures attacking the news media and was a critique of what later Republicans would label “fake news”.
“In
the United States today, we have more than our share of the nattering nabobs of
negativism. They have formed their own
4-H Club - the “hopeless, hysterical hypochondriacs of history” “…As long as they have their own association,
crooks will flourish. As long as they
have their own television networks, paid for by their own advertisers, they
will continue to have their own commentators. It is time for America to quit catering to the
pabulum peddlers and the permissive. It
is time to speak up forcefully for the conservative cause."
It wasn’t a new complaint for the aggressively alliterative Agnew and certainly represented well the opinions of Richard Nixon (1913–1994; US president 1969-1974) whose long list (and it was literally a list) of enemies included many journalists, editors and media proprietors. In November 1969, Agnew had appeared at the Midwestern Regional Republican Conference in Des Moines, Iowa where he attacked “…this little group of men” who he accused of wielding “a free hand in selecting, presenting and interpreting” the news. Intellectuals, he labeled “…an effete corps of impudent snobs”, a sentiment Donald Trump (b 1946; US president 2017-2021) would later recycle, the phraseology simplified so his “deplorables” would comprehend. Agnew’s speeches are not classics in the art of rhetoric but remain landmarks in the culture wars which began in the early 1960s and which are being fought still.
Concurrent with though not related to the Watergate affair, in early 1973, Agnew was under investigation on suspicion of conspiracy, bribery, extortion and tax fraud. While for months denying everything (always good legal advice which succeeds more often than it should), Agnew eventually was forced to negotiate a plea-bargain whereby he would resign from office but avoid jail. On 10 October 1973, Agnew pleaded no contest to a single felony charge of tax evasion and resigned, not a few of those he’d earlier derided as “crooks” not reluctant to ensure the juxtaposition was well publicized. Facing impeachment for his role in the Watergate affair cover-up, President Nixon (who earlier had made his soon infamous “I am not a crook” speech, followed within a year, saved from prosecution by a presidential pardon, granted by Gerald Ford (1913–2006; US president 1974-1977) who had been Nixon’s choice to replace Agnew as vice-president.
Lemon, Orange & Passionfruit Flummery
Ingredients
115g (½ cup) caster sugar
2 tablespoons plain flour
1 tablespoon powdered gelatine
250ml (1 cup) water
2 oranges, juiced & strained
1 lemon, juiced & strained
125ml (½ cup) fresh passionfruit pulp
Whipped cream, to serve
2 tablespoons passionfruit pulp, (extra, to spread on top)
Method
(1) Place the sugar,
flour, gelatine, water, orange juice and lemon juice in a medium saucepan. Use
a balloon whisk to whisk until well combined. Bring to the boil over medium
heat, stirring constantly. Simmer for 2 minutes.
(2) Pour the mixture
into a heatproof bowl and place in the fridge for 1 hour or until the mixture
begins to set around the edges. Stir in the passionfruit and transfer to a
large bowl. Use an electric beater to beat for 15 minutes or until the mixture
is thick and pale.
(3) Pour the mixture
evenly into four 310ml (1¼ cups) serving glasses. Cover the glass tightly
with plastic wrap and place in the fridge for 1-2 hours or until the mixture is
set.
(4) Serve topped
with whipped cream and with extra passionfruit pulp.
