Charybdis & Scylla

Charybdis (pronounced kuh-rib-dis)

(1) A dangerous whirlpool in the Strait of Messina off the north-east coast of Sicily, lying opposite Scylla.  The modern name is Galofalo (or Garofalo).

(2) In classical mythology, a daughter of Gaea and Poseidon, a ship-devouring monster mentioned in Homer and later identified with the whirlpool Charybdis; A personification of the above whirlpool as a female monster.

(3) In casual use, any dangerous whirlpool.

From antiquity: A Latinized form of the Ancient Greek Χάρυβδις (Kharybdis or Khárubdis) of unknown origin. 

Scylla (pronounced sil-uh)

(1) A rock in the Strait of Messina off the southern coast of Italy.  The modern name is Scilla.  

(2) In classical mythology, a sea nymph who was transformed into a sea monster; later identified with the rock Scylla; a personification of the rock as a ravenous monster.

(3) A mud crab, mangrove crab of the taxonomic genus within the family Portunidae.

(4) In astronomy, the main belt asteroid 155 Scylla.

(5) In Greek mythology a princess, daughter of King Nisos of Megara, who fell in love with King Minos and betrayed her city to him.

From antiquity: A Latinized form of the Ancient Greek Σκύλλα (Skúlla) of unknown origin although there’s speculation it may be related to the Ancient Greek skyllein (to tear).

Between Scylla and Charybdis

The proverbial Latin incidit in scyllam cupiens vitare charybdim (he runs into Scylla, wishing to avoid Charybdis) describes a choice between two unpalatable alternatives; those situations where one must choose the lesser of two evils.  In English, the sentiment is expressed also as as being caught “between the devil and the deep blue sea” or “between a rock and a hard place".  Charybdis was the child of Gaea and Poseidon.  Born a nymph who served her father, after displeasing Zeus, she was cursed and became a much-feared sea monster residing in the Strait of Messina.  As a nymph, Charybdis was responsible for flooding dry land in her father’s kingdom so is credited the world over with the ebb and flow of the daily tides but this all changed when she drew the ire of mighty Zeus and although there are two stories of how she came to be cursed, both end the same.  In the first, Charybdis became overzealous and started to flood too much land.  Angered by this, Zeus trapped and transformed her, forcing her to live at the Strait of Messina on the side closest to Italy.  In the second account, she was stealing and eating sheep belonging to Heracles, which he had stolen from Geryon in his tenth labor. That Charybdis had stolen what Heracles had rightfully kidnapped enraged Zeus, and he punished her.

So, she ended up transformed and imprisoned at the Strait of Messina.  Trapped either in a cave or under the rock on which a huge fig tree grew, she was required to continue her duties, but only three times daily for ebb, and three for flow.  Because of this symmetry of action, a huge whirlpool formed in the strait, creating a danger to all who attempted to pass, a danger is compounded by there being on the Sicilian side of the strait, the monster Scylla, who would snatch sailors from ships that cruised too near her perch.  The most famous descriptions of Charybdis are in the tales of the journeys of Odysseus.  Odysseus knew the dangers posed by Charybdis and Scylla and asked Circe for a way safely to pass between them.  She said there was no truly safe passage, but that were he to sail closer to Scylla, he would lose only a few men, while in sailing close to Charybdis, he would lose his crew, his ship, and his life.  Odysseus did as advised, losing six men but saving his ship.  On his journey back, having wrecked his ship and lost all his crew, Odysseus again encountered Charybdis though now it was just him and a few salvaged fragments of his ship he had lashed into a raft.  This time, she was sucking the seas downward and Odysseus survived only by clinging to a limb of the fig tree on her rock but his raft was drawn into her abyss.  For hours he hung to the tree, waiting for Charybdis to relent, hoping to regain his raft which, sure enough, returned to the surface intact.  He recovered it, with his hands, paddled quickly away before.

Odysseus facing the choice between Scylla and Charybdis (circa 1795), oil on canvas by Johann Heinrich Füssli (1741-1825)

The myths of Antiquity suggest several goddesses as mother of Scylla.  In the Odyssey, the mother is an obscure sea goddess named Crataeis though later scholars proposed Crataeis was another name for Ceto, a primordial sea goddess, or Hecate, the triple-bodied goddess of magic and passageways.  A fourth candidate is Lamia, a monstrous shape-shifter and infamous man-eater.  He father was either Phorcys, a primordial sea god, or an obscure character named Titon.  Scylla when young was a ravishing nymph, living among the sea nymphs who wrought havoc in the hearts of young Greek men. She had milky skin, hair like silk, and was hauntingly beautiful; men fell in love with her in an instant but beauty doomed her.  She loved to bathe in the pools by the sea side, combing her long hair with the nymphs’ combs and gossiping with them about those she had evaded.  The nymphs tried to warn Scylla men became enraged when spurned but the young maiden remained light-hearted and careless, sunning herself nude on the beaches and luxuriating in the tide pools.

One day, a sea god name Glaucus caught sight of the lovely nymph and captivated, he approached her but on her dainty feet she fled.  Grumpy Glaucus complained of this rejection to Circe, a sea witch and brewer of potions.  Little did Glaucus know that Circe longed for him and when she heard of his desire for Scylla, was so angered, secretly she crept to Scylla’s favorite pool which she poisoned with a terrible potion.  When the poor nymph returned to bathe, her legs were twisted into yapping dogs, and she felt a burning pain as six monstrous heads sprouted from her back.  When Glaucus saw her again, he was horrified and heartbroken, abandoning Scylla to her fate and cursing Circe for her act of jealous evil.

After her transformation, Scylla hid in the cliffs overlooking her old tide pool where she took out her rage against men, whose unsought passion she blamed for her fate, attacking their ships as they sailed by.  Rejected by Glaucus, Circe had fallen in love with Odysseus and for some time kept him and his crew imprisoned on her island but when she saw how he longed to return home, she released him and told him how to make his voyage safely. She warned him of the dangers of Scylla and Charybdis, telling him to hide below deck as he passed the monster’s cave.  He was thus saved and Scylla devoured only six of his crew.  After she attacked other important voyagers (most notably the Argonauts), the gods grew tired of Scylla’s bloodbath and decided to add her to the twelve labors of Heracles.  Incredibly, the hero managed to slay her by cutting off each of her heads, one by one and, for a while, she served as one of the guardians of the underworld. Then, she was resurrected by her father. Finally, Poseidon took pity on the still sweet-faced monster and transformed her into a giant rock, thereby ending the miserable cycle of bitterness and revenge her life had become.